A year-by-year list of the Champions and Runners-up from The Greater Cleveland Amateur Golf Championships, along with the winner of the Senior Cleveland Amateur Championship, from the early years of these events, 1993-2002:
| 2002 – Manakiki | |||
| Champion | Norton Brick | 72-70-71 | 213 |
| Runner Up | Brian Krusoe | 73-74-69 | 216 |
| Seniors | Frank Tuscano | 79-75-76 | 230 |
| 2001 – Sleepy Hollow | |||
| Champion | Norton Brick | 72-72-73 | 217 |
| Runner Up | Joe Hurtuk | 72-78-71 | 221 |
| Seniors | John Betonte | 72-81-71 | 224 |
| 2000 – Manakiki | |||
| Champion | Norton Brick | 67-74-76 | 217 |
| Runners Up | Ted Koelsch | 71-71-77 | 219 |
| Glyn Price | 68-76-75 | 219 | |
| Seniors | John Betonte | 72-76-74 | 222 |
| 1999 – Sleepy Hollow | |||
| Champion | Matthew Creech | 73-75 | 148 |
| Runners Up | Scott Heran | 76-74 | 150 |
| Brian Polick | 77-73 | 150 | |
| Seniors | Not played | ||
| 1998 – R1) Manakiki; R2) Sleepy Hollow | |||
| Champion | Doug Hauenstein | 71-72 | 143 |
| Runner Up | Allen Freeman | 72-73 | 145 |
| Seniors | Not played | ||
| 1997 – R1) Shawnee Hills; R2) Manakiki | |||
| Champion | Richard Hubbard* | 73-76 | 149 |
| Runners Up | Rick Campbell | 75-74 | 149 |
| Jack Elber | 75-74 | 149 | |
*won playoff with par on 1st hole | |||
| Seniors | Jim Rockow | 74-73 | 147 |
| 1996 – R1) Big Met; R2) Sleepy Hollow | |||
| Champion | Brad Steven | 69-76 | 145 |
| Runner Up | John Douglas | 78-72 | 150 |
| Seniors | Lloyd Chirdon | 78-85 | 163 |
| 1995 – R1) Shawnee Hills; R2) Sleepy Hollow | |||
| Champion | Joe Benich | 75-78 | 153 |
| Runner Up | Jim Rockow | 74-81 | 155 |
| Seniors | Richard Centa | 84-84 | 168 |
| 1994 – R1) Pine Ridge; R2) Manakiki | |||
| Champion | John Niedzialek | 74-76 | 150 |
| Runner Up | Bob Delaat | 76-76 | 152 |
| Seniors | Joe Danolfo | 159 | |
| 1993 – Sleepy Hollow | |||
| Champion | Scott Piesen | 77 | |
| Runners Up | Richard Hubbard | 79 | |
| Steve Schaefer | 79 | ||
| Seniors | Joe Danolfo | 84 | |
— Allen Freeman
